remembering meme pebbles in the pool

this was shortly before slauti met kris for the first time in his life.

'Twas on the same day I met Brian Foote, the guy with reportedly the best joke/minute rate in the programming conferences world. As far as I know, Brian is the author of the 'xml is diet cobol' meme.

A while ago Tobi Schäfer remembered the Diet Cobol meme and asked a question as to its exact meaning of wether java or xml. Joey deVilla obviously likes the meme too () could not decide on what and incidently quoted Tobi's question alongside two other links of which:

Martin Fowler says that 'Java is ..'. Travis Grigg's says that 'XML is ...'.

Both heard Brian's talk at OOPSLA2005 and quote him, so one quote must be wrong.

It was 3 years ago (after I had met him personally and heard him say) that I quoted Brian here and here. The later quote still seems to be numero duo in Pagerank, not because of Brian's genial meme but because of the extremley clever trick of quoting him inside a bluff story on X#. There I too say that 'XML is Diet Cobol'.

Mariann Unterluggauer quoted Brian on 14.05.2002. She says it sounded nice but she didn't quite get what it meant that 'xml was diet cobol'. In a comment on langreiter.com 624 days ago I quoted Brian's meme in a way that I said it were under your desktop and with transformations which is only a weak indication that I thought it was XML.

Next thing, Tobi requoted deVilla because of this nice little free grafic, i suppose. I am pretty sure that Travis Grigg quotes Brian correctly: "One of the funny quotes I heard Brian say in his presentation last night: "XSLT is kind of like lisp... but with horns." He also referred to XML as Diet Cobol.".

A Google Search on Dec. 22 2005 13:45 turns out 'ungefähr 131' occurences. A click to the second page strangly reduces this figure to 'ungefähr 68' and kills the rest of the pagelinks.

With haboglabloggin' on top and tinyville in second place one could firstly say that p3k is the waxing and slauti is the waning prophet of the great Brian's dietary meme and secondly guess that Brian uses the meme in his speaking and not in his writing, because he is not in the ranking top, but:

Is Google doing geolocation weighting in Pagerank? My impression they do is getting ever stronger. It gives you the feeling of having meaning on the web, which might be a large part of their business model, meaning the model of creating the values they are paid for.

If it were not so then until OOPSLA 2005 Brian would have landed his meme with Marianne and me and maybe lots of other people who either: do not write on the web did not understand the meme or have any other reason to not spread it which I do absolutely know nothing about.

Funny then also that Tobi's question and Brians OOPSLA talk met in the spatial and temporal domain.

However that be: We here at tiny keep endorsing this meme and are also extremely happy about the 'lisp with horns' meme. Pattern research in the funny style rulez.

PS: Beware of it-no.info, it's got spyware.

 

found an old answer. hah, about some people i really keep track: here is the piece:

I call it Diet Cobol, because it is about RECORDS and STRUCTURES, just like Cobol Because Larry Ellison won, and pure Objects lost. Because META won (tables of database column names) won, and objects lost (behavior is much too dangerous to let loose on the web, witness viruses). Mainly, data is easier to charge a fee for ($$$) than code (believe it or not). (brian foote, octubre 2002 on "xml is like diet cobol")

... plink  

 

Yeah, and amen to that!

... plink  


... answer!
 
last updated: 23.03.25, 07:18
menu
status
Youre not logged in ... Login
... antville home

Terms of Service
About us / Imprint


April 2025
So.Mo.Di.Mi.Do.Fr.Sa.
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930
März
Made with Antville

recently modified
D'après ce que je vois
vous avez tout à fait raison, Mr. Tobi.
by MaryW (01.03.25, 08:34)
...
La crisi consiste appunto nel fatto che il vecchio muore e il nuovo non può nascere: in questo interregno si verificano i fenomeni morbosi piú....
by tobi (28.02.25, 16:22)
...
Haschimiten-Familie Vater:Husain ibn 'AliEmir von Mekka von 1908 - 1916König des Hedschas von 1916 - 1924 Sohn Faisal:Verhandlungsführer der "Araber" in Paris König des Irak von 1921....
by StefanL (19.01.25, 06:26)
Ich habe eh
einen Esseh über den Kulturpessimismus, der ja grundlegend mehr reaktionär als konservativ ist, in Arbeit. Wird aber noch dauern.
by StefanL (10.01.25, 23:50)
Jaaa!
Ich geb ja gerne zu, dass der Neid aus mir spricht. ;-)
by StefanL (10.01.25, 23:46)
...
Aha soso ein Professor h.k. (honore kurza).
by tobi (10.01.25, 23:30)
I totally agree
mit der Meinung, dass das Hemisphärenmodell überholt ist. Die mediale Lust am Untergang hat eine rational kalkulierendes Element auf der einen Seite und massenpsychologische Element, dass....
by StefanL (10.01.25, 20:15)
Woher kommt diese Lust am Untergang?
Friedrich Sieburg kommentierte »die Tendenz der Medien, unentwegt den Weltuntergang durch einen Atomkrieg vorauszusagen als weinerliche, kaum zu ertragende Geschwätzigkeit. Sie sei auch deswegen absurd,....
by tobi (10.01.25, 19:18)
Read the books,
watched the series for a while. Got distracted then. Did NOT buy the T-Shirt. Interesting problem. Thanks! Slice, slice, very slice. Thank you for not killing....
by StefanL (06.01.25, 11:39)
...
Slice, slice, very nice.
by tobi (05.01.25, 23:31)
...
😻
by tobi (18.12.24, 12:27)
We could just barely
keep the censor's office and the press team of the president-elect from intervention but here are our apologies and our thanks for these valuable hints....
by MaryW (17.12.24, 23:37)
...
The (correct) first name of Mr. Zelenskyj is the Ukrainian Володи́мир, not (of all things) the Russian Влади́мир 😿 Second name is Oleksandrovych. Ложка дьогтю у бочці....
by tobi (16.12.24, 19:15)
Du hast recht,
Universal-Genies brauchen wir echt keine mehr. Ich wollte eh nur sagen: Things are going to slide, slide in all directions. Won't be nothing, won't be nothing you....
by MaryW (31.10.24, 23:13)
...
Hm. Ich glaub, da gibt es schon noch einige Kandidat*innen. Mir fällt spontan Lisz Hirn ein. Ich fürchte nur, die schaffen es nicht mehr, so....
by tobi (03.10.24, 19:21)
Das sind
wirklich die allerletzten, diese Streberschweine. Aber sonst auch.
by StefanL (18.09.24, 08:42)
Es gibt sogar
Verbrecher, die das ganze WE zusätzlich durcharbeiten, um Pegelkarten zu bauen. Das sind dann die allerletzten.
by gHack (17.09.24, 18:56)
Geändert
Inzwischen hat Herr Fidler den Fehler erkannt und korrigiert sowie sich inzwischen bei den LeserInnen entschuldigt. Nur damit das nicht untergeht. Wir haben hier in der....
by StefanL (21.02.22, 09:17)
There has been evidence
that the important and successful ideas in MSFT - like licensing the Unix source code in the 70ies and learning from it and licensing QDOS....
by StefanL (02.01.22, 11:18)
Now
I think I maybe know what you meant. It is the present we know best and the future we invent. And history is mostly used....
by StefanL (02.01.22, 09:51)
???
Hey, it's just a phrase wishing to convey that you're always smarter after the event than before it.
by StefanL (28.12.21, 07:35)
Addendum
Oracle is now mentioned in the English Wikipedia article on teletext and even has its own article here. Electra has one too.
by MaryW (22.12.21, 07:11)
We have grossly erred
At least in point 5. We thought, people would have come to the conclusion that permanently listening to directive voices as an adult is so....
by MaryW (21.12.21, 07:42)
Did not want to spell the names out
Ingrid Thurnher should have been easy, as she is pictured in the article. Harald F. is an insider joke, the only media journalist in Austria,....
by StefanL (19.12.21, 08:45)
...
with four letters it becomes easier though i am not sure with hafi… anyhoo, inms guessing acronyms or whatever this is. *it’s not my steckenpferd
by tobi (24.11.21, 20:49)

RSS Feed