loglo sans glo  
 
Computers, Governance, Writing

Chris Langreiter has linked an extremely interesting article on kurzweilai.net.
Is AI Near a Takeoff Point? by J. Storrs Hall

A Short Quote
"There are two separable questions here: Should humanity as a whole build machines that do all its work for it? And, if we do, how should the fruits of that productivity be distributed, if not by existing market mechanisms?

If we say yes to the first question, would the future be so bad? The robots, properly designed and administered, would be working to provide all that wealth for mankind, and we would get the benefit without having to work. Joy calls this "a textbook dystopia", but Moravec writes, "Contrary to the fears of some engaged in civilization's work ethic, our tribal past has prepared us well for lives as idle rich. In a good climate and location the hunter-gatherer's lot can be pleasant indeed. An afternoon's outing picking berries or catching fish—what we civilized types would recognize as a recreational weekend—provides life's needs for several days. The rest of the time can be spent with children, socializing, or simply resting."

In other words, Moravec believes that, in the medium run, handing our economy over to robots will reclaim the birthright of leisure we gave up in the Faustian bargain of agriculture.

As for the second question, about distribution, perhaps we should ask the ultra-intelligent AIs what to do.
"

Our comments
What makes that text so interesting are the questions it poses. It rounds up some of the more interesting answers too. It crucibly leaves out one possible development that Herbert Frank described in a sophisticated fashion in his Dune sequel. Anti machine computing rebellion. I commented in this sense on Chris' log.

The net realization from this is that it's time to broaden the good ole AI debate again. It has been pushed into a near invisible niche twice or even 3 times since its inception. Not good. Let us give it some prominence. Let us keep in mind also that it is a dangerous and complicated debate that could easily accelerate anti machine aggression if, like in the past, its promoters do nothing but create awe, false promises and irritation with people at large and more so with the political elites. Clear thinking and understanding is badly in need. But the debate also requires a lot more work and participation from non computing experts if not participation by all the population at large. Tough communication work is waiting. Might be not funny but will be necessary.

Addendum
Just detected that motzes finds the story to be "yet another annoying chapter of kurzweil's dilemma". I asked her why.

A final statement
Yiyeh tov (means "will be fine")
Why? Because there are many allies, not least the universe which contrary to what many scientists believe is good by nature.


ANTSCD: Writing
The history, development and evolution of the world's writing systems

Tobi Schäfer pointed us to an equally important text on the evolution of writing systems. Krysstal.com is a United Kingdom based educational and information web site by Kryss Katsiavriades and Talaat Qureshi in London. On first sight it looks like an excellent place to easily study topics like language, football, physics, democracy and more.

Media system and writing especially despite all of the academic traditions are still understudied in my opinion. The emergence of sites like this one fit nicely into the current McLuhan revival. Marshal McLuhan's books have experienced a lot of misunderstanding by half competent study and and large gaps in the knowledge of the evolution of humanity's media systems. Historical and political analysis is still strongly biased to West Eurasian history. Weakly connected and unbalanced pieces of half knowledge are a very dangerous thing, ideologically. Then and again ideas can play large and tragic roles in the material world. Take care. But then again: It's getting better all the time, somehow.

 
last updated: 02.12.2008, 11:35
Youre not logged in ... Login
recently modified
ist keine Montage
Das sieht dort einfach so aus.
by StefanL (02.12.2008, 11:35)
Was ist das?
Montage? Von wem?
by Goldchen (02.12.2008, 10:35)
und alle denken jetzt darüber nach: was das denn bedeuten mag ...
und alle denken jetzt darüber nach: was das denn bedeuten mag ...
by motzes (06.11.2008, 22:55)
wochenenddienst.
wochenenddienst.
by motzes (13.10.2008, 21:42)
Pietas Austriaca.
Pietas Austriaca.
by tobi (13.10.2008, 18:10)
muhahaha!
muhahaha!
by kris (08.07.2008, 10:21)
Wirklich toll
Die Serie war wirklich toll. Ich hoffe auf Staffel 2 und natürlich darauf, dass auch diese hier gezeigt wird. Ich werde mal in schauen, wenn ich in Israel bin, ob es dort die DvD zu einem erschwinglichen Preis gibt. Außerdem weiß dort vielleicht jemand, ob eine zweite Staffel geplant ist....
by Goldchen (06.07.2008, 19:58)
kennste das schon? www.youtube.com
kennste das schon? www.youtube.com
by koxinga (25.06.2008, 15:15)
Da möchte ich viele Zitate. Vielleicht sogar das/die Buch/Bücher leihen.
Da möchte ich viele Zitate. Vielleicht sogar das/die Buch/Bücher leihen.
by Goldchen (29.04.2008, 09:16)
Finde ich auch. Schade, dass heute keine Probe ist. Das geht mir richtig ab.
Finde ich auch. Schade, dass heute keine Probe ist. Das geht mir richtig ab.
by Goldchen (29.04.2008, 09:15)
Dezember 2008
MoDiMiDoFrSaSo
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031
November

XML version of this page

Made with Antville
powered by
Helma Object Publisher